The Author-Editor Relationship — Drew Hayes Novels
Unfortunately, not all author-editor relationships run this smoothly. Open up for 5 keys to enjoy a good author-editor relationship. Jul 25, I see authors getting frustrated. “Just tell me how much editing will cost!” They cry, annoyed at vague or incomplete answers. The editors are. Sep 7, it is critical to learn how, when, and why to rely on an editor's experience and wisdom. Too often what could and should be a beautiful.
The editor also identifies and, in cooperation with the author, clarifies unclear writing, theological or historical inaccuracies, and potentially offensive material. Some see the editor as a supercritical, academic-monastic individual who cackles as he edits a manuscript so heavily that writers can't recognize their own work. Others idealize the editor as a knight in shining armor who will rescue a manuscript or an author from obscurity, make the work great, and bring huge success!
The truth is somewhere in between. In Christian publishing, the editor and the writer have the same goals and serve the same Lord, but they are coming to the task from different angles. This sometimes makes for a nebulous world in which the rules seem unclear. Ideally, author and editor will maintain a context of cooperation and teamwork, and within that context the editor fills necessary roles on behalf of both the publisher and the author.
“The Symbiotic Relationship between Editor and Author” / Tamara Hart Heiner
The editor and the writer are coworkers. Throughout the editorial process the editor gives honest feedback and offers constructive criticism.
If some elements in the book do not work, are offensive to the intended readership, are theologically questionable or simply unclear, it is the editor's responsibility to work with the author to resolve the problem. Trust is at the core of the editor-author relationship. His new manuscript was in editing with a small but well-respected press and the edits he was receiving from their top-notch editor were not at all to his liking.
Everything is getting altered.
The Writer-Editor Relationship – Los Angeles Editors and Writers Group
I told him to seriously consider all edits, not as a form of sabotage, but as possibilities and see if maybe a compromise in the manuscript could be made. I then told him that if he truly wasn't comfortable with the amount of edits or inserts, he should stand his ground and not accept the edits. Most experienced editors make small positive changes that enhance the story.
You can accept the edits or not but sometimes you can see that the edits don't change the original story at all; they simply help it flow a little more easily.
5 keys to a good author-editor relationship
No really good editor will want to drastically change a manuscript that has been accepted by a publisher. Going over the edits from the first book in my Cate Harlow Private Investigation series I was surprised at a line my editor had inserted for my main male character, Detective Will Benigni, to say.
The line came after a somewhat heated exchange between that character and another male character, Giles Barrett. The original scene that I had written had Will make an "obscene gesture" towards Giles after the argument and then walk away.
I knew that any readers of the book would know what that meant. But my editor wanted it to go further and inserted certain words that can accompany that gesture.
I had created the character and that wasn't what I felt would happen in that scene. My character wouldn't say it; he would just walk away. I knew that the gesture was enough.
We went back and forth over that one edit for quite a few emails and SKYPE sessions while my editor, a man I knew and respected, tried to convince me to keep the line in. I firmly refused and the line was deleted. Now I didn't feel smug as in an "I-won-you-lost" scenario; of course not.
But I did feel a certain satisfaction that I had been true to my character by holding my ground. My editor went on to make a few very good minor changes which I accepted and our working relationship continued to be a good one. We even jokingly called each other "my favorite sparring partner.